If you enjoy good food and good company, then you will love the restaurants in St. Augustine, Florida! If you’re looking for a delicious meal while vacationing in St. Augustine, look no further!
Whether you’re in the mood for fresh seafood, Southern comfort food, or a juicy steak, these restaurants will not disappoint. And with so many unique and historic dining experiences to choose from, you’ll want to come back again and again to sample them all!
With so many different types of cuisine to choose from, you’ll never get bored of eating out here. And with the friendly atmosphere of the city, you’re sure to have a great time no matter where you go.
Here are our picks of St. Augustine restaurants you should visit!
1. Casa Benedetto’s Ristorante
After shifting twice after the restaurant’s first opening in 2009, the owners decided to settle in St. Augustine as its final site.
The restaurant offers mouthwatering delicacies that are truly Italian.
One of the best restaurants in St. Augustine, with a laid-back atmosphere ideal for social gatherings.
Don’t look elsewhere for the top birthday restaurants in St. Augustine since you’ll adore the roomy yet cozy setting here made possible by soft lighting and home decor.
The prepared food is ideal for anyone looking for a taste of Italy in Florida. Following the traditional traditions of Sicilian immigrants who arrived in the United States in the 1900s, the food is prepared fresh to order.
And the recipes are absolutely delicious!
Veal Sorrentino made by Benedetto is simply wonderful. As the buttered cutlet, topped with onions, mushrooms, and prosciutto ham, interacts with the sweet sherry demi-glace, you’ll appreciate the burst of flavors in your mouth. It’s a culinary pleasure.
This restaurant has a vibe that is perfect for social gatherings, making it unquestionably one of the coolest spots to eat in St. Augustine.
For the health-conscious, delectable smoothies, flavorful salads, and fresh wraps are ideal. One of the top restaurants in the city is without a doubt Crave.
You’ll adore its cool and hip atmosphere, with pop art and cheerful wall colors that will really make you smile all the time.
The meals are excellent, have inventive titles, and use fresh, regional ingredients.
With its combination of carrots, red bell peppers, romaine, scallops, and cilantro, among others, drenched in that delectable teriyaki tempeh and garlic nutritional yeast dressing, the Happy Belly Wrap is a must-try.
True to the dish’s name, you’ll have a happy belly, trust me.
3. Woodpeckers Backyard BBQ
Woodpecker’s Backyard Barbecue is a small, family-owned BBQ joint that can be found in the back roads of St. Augustine. Woodpecker’s BBQ is a southern low-and-slow barbecue restaurant that offers a variety of lunch options and an award-winning datil sauce.
Woodpeckers employ three pit masters who prepare turkey, chicken, brisket, and sausages daily, as well as their own datil sauces. Datil baked beans, datil cornbread and other datil dishes are just a few of the many options.
With Jacksonville, close by, you should choose Woodpeckers Backyard BBQ if you’re looking for eateries around.
This restaurant is on my list of neighborhood eateries that offer the most delectable smoked meals, all in a relaxed all-American grill house atmosphere.
Try the brisket with a side of datil corn and beans!
The soft and well-smoked brisket is the ideal partner for spicy side dishes. You’ll undoubtedly enjoy your best lunch in St. Augustine or the surrounding area!
4. The Press
With its all-American food blended with European and Asian flavors, this is one of the most well-liked restaurants to sample in St. Augustine.
One of the best meals in St. Augustine can be found at this eatery off State Road 16. The restaurant offers wonderful cuisine that has won over both locals and tourists, whether you’re looking for breakfast or brunch.
You’ll adore this place’s comfortable atmosphere as well.
It’s one of the more laid-back restaurants in the neighborhood, with a pub-like atmosphere and helpful staff who will go above and beyond to meet your needs.
Don’t overlook the Conquistador Burger, which has won numerous awards.
The datil pepper-stuffed burger on house-made bread with bacon, cheese, chorizo, manchego, and chimichurri will undoubtedly win your heart with its exquisite flavor combination.
5. Collage Restaurant
Collage Restaurant is ideal for the foodie seeking the ultimate in exquisite dining with a hint of familiarity. The restaurant offers worldwide cuisine made with home recipes that have been refined over time.
In St. Augustine, you won’t have to travel far to find fine dining.
This eatery near I-95 provides the ideal ambiance thanks to its dim lighting, vintage furnishings, and a brick fireplace that may keep you toasty while you enjoy your meal.
This restaurant is one of the best for supper in St. Augustine because it serves a wide variety of delectable dishes, including steaks, pasta, and seafood, all created with fresh ingredients and presented on plates with an eye-catching flare.
The Duo Di Manzo is the ideal dinner’s main course.
The prosciutto-gorgonzola cream and crispy cream onions on top of the grilled beef tenderloin medallions’ rich flavors will win you over. Trust me, it’s a culinary masterpiece.
6. Sunset Grille
With a reputation for serving comfort cuisine and seafood in a warm, beachside setting, this restaurant has been in business for more than 30 years.
If you’re looking for a cozy place to enjoy some comfort food and seafood, look no further than Sunset Grille in St. Augustine, Florida.
This local favorite is known for its warm and welcoming atmosphere, and its menu features all of your favorite comfort foods.
The Sunset Grille is a great place to eat if you’re in St. Augustine., there’s something for everyone at Sunset Grille. And of course, no meal is complete without one of their signature desserts.
The restaurant offers more than just scrumptious meals made with regional products. With its wooden floors and, of course, its shark wall mount statues, it also emanates the ideal beach vibe!
So next time you’re in the mood for a cozy night out, be sure to check out Sunset Grille.
7. Llama Restaurant
One of the best restaurants in St. Augustine serving genuine Peruvian cuisine is this quaint establishment, operated by Cordon Bleu-trained Marcel Vizcarra.
When you visit St. Augustine, experience Peru in this quaint restaurant with a cozy atmosphere.
The dining establishment’s historical decor and images hanging from the ceiling that depicts a piece of Peru will transport you to every region of the nation.
You will be in awe of the artistic food arrangements, with many elements successfully serving an aesthetic purpose.
Of course, the flavors are equally deserving of appreciation; they are rendered rich by aji pepper, a staple of Peruvian cuisine.
The octopus, the star of this dish, is made savory with Alfonso olive aioli and Peruvian peppers in the Pulpo, which is my favorite.
8. The Blue Hen Café
With its comfort food that has a Southern flavor and is served in a casual environment, this restaurant is on my list of St. Augustine eateries that are worth a visit.
When you enter this restaurant, you’ll actually feel like you’re in an art gallery.
The white walls are lined with vibrant pop art, more than enough to satisfy your visual appetite.
The diner is ideal for social gatherings because it has a cool, laid-back vibe that you’ll appreciate.
My favorite dish is The Yard Bird, which features buttermilk chicken and scallops as the star ingredients.
Enjoy the mouthwatering fusion of beef and fish tastes drenched in bacon gravy with Vidalia onion caramelization. Your dining experience will be properly capped off by the collard’s side dish.
If you’re looking for a good meal while visiting St. Augustine, Florida, you’ll have plenty of great restaurants to choose from.
Whether you’re in the mood for seafood, American cuisine, or something in between, you’ll find it here.
From fresh seafood to traditional Spanish fare, there’s something to suit every taste. And with so many great options, you’re sure to find a new favorite spot during your visit!
And if you’re looking for something in between, there are plenty of great options to choose from as well.
No matter what your taste buds are craving, you’ll find it in St. Augustine. So come hungry and enjoy all that this historic city has to offer!